Both are evidence-based in-clinic options for treatment-resistant depression,
but they differ sharply on insurance coverage, administration, and regulatory standing.
If cost or coverage is your main constraint, this comparison is the decision point.
If you need insurance coverage
Start with Spravato. It is the only ketamine-family depression treatment here with FDA approval and broad payer pathways.
- Ask whether your plan requires failure of two or more antidepressants.
- Ask whether the clinic handles prior authorization.
- Confirm the total visit cost, not just the drug copay.
If you can self-pay
Compare in-clinic IV/IM ketamine against at-home oral programs by supervision, not just price.
- Some self-pay clinics offer ketamine-assisted psychotherapy (KAP), a model that pairs sublingual or IM dosing with structured talk therapy. This differs from a straight medical-infusion clinic that focuses on IV dosing and monitoring alone.
- In-clinic care gives more monitoring during acute dissociation and blood-pressure changes.
- At-home care varies widely; read the at-home ketamine safety checklist and avoid programs that skip medical history and follow-up.
- Ask what happens after the initial series if symptoms return.
If you want psilocybin
Psilocybin is promising for depression, but access is very different from ketamine.
- There is no FDA-approved psilocybin product.
- Trials are the most medically structured route.
- Oregon and Colorado programs are legal state-regulated services, usually self-pay and non-medical.
If risk factors apply
Do the clinician conversation before booking anything.
- Psychosis or bipolar I history changes the risk calculus for classic psychedelics.
- Uncontrolled hypertension or cardiac disease matters for ketamine and MDMA-family therapies.
- Do not taper SSRIs/SNRIs without the prescriber who manages them.
What to expect if treatment works
Ketamine-family treatment is usually fast-acting but not one-and-done.
Some people notice mood shifts within hours or days; durability often
depends on repeated dosing, psychotherapy, medication management, and
a maintenance plan. Psilocybin trials sometimes report longer follow-up
effects after one or two dosing sessions, but access is narrower and
the blinding problem makes headline effect sizes hard to interpret.
- Early non-response: ask when the provider decides a protocol is not helping.
- Relapse planning: ask what happens at 4, 8, and 12 weeks after the initial series.
- Integration: schedule therapy support before treatment starts, not after the first difficult session.
Frequently asked
What is the most realistic psychedelic-adjacent option for treatment-resistant depression in the US?
For most US patients, the practical first branch is ketamine-family care: Spravato if insurance coverage matters, or clinic-based IV/IM ketamine if paying out of pocket is possible. Psilocybin is not FDA-approved and is legally accessible mainly through clinical trials or regulated Oregon and Colorado service programs.
Is Spravato the same thing as IV ketamine?
No. Spravato is esketamine nasal spray, FDA-approved for treatment-resistant depression and administered only in certified offices under a REMS program. IV ketamine usually means racemic ketamine infusion used off-label for depression; it is commonly self-pay and not governed by the Spravato REMS.
Should I stop antidepressants before ketamine or psilocybin?
Do not stop or taper psychiatric medication without the prescriber who manages it. Ketamine is often used while patients remain on antidepressants. Psilocybin effects can be reduced by SSRIs/SNRIs, but any taper decision requires medical supervision.
What should I ask a ketamine clinic before booking?
Ask who performs the medical evaluation, whether they screen cardiovascular and psychosis/mania risk, what route and dose protocol they use, how blood pressure and distress are handled during sessions, whether integration support is included, and what maintenance or exit plan they recommend after the initial series.
Who makes Spravato?
Spravato (esketamine) is made by <a href="https://www.janssen.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Janssen Pharmaceuticals</a>, the pharmaceutical subsidiary of Johnson & Johnson. It was FDA-approved in 2019 for treatment-resistant depression and is only available through the Spravato REMS (Risk Evaluation and Mitigation Strategy) program, which requires administration in a certified office with 2 hours of post-dose monitoring.
Is Spravato the same drug as ketamine?
Related, not identical. Ketamine used in clinics is usually the racemic (both-mirror-image) form. Esketamine is just one of those two mirror-image molecules, isolated and formulated as a nasal spray. Only the Janssen-branded esketamine nasal spray is FDA-approved and REMS-regulated; IV, IM, sublingual, and compounded ketamine are chemically related but are prescribed off-label, not as Spravato.
How does Spravato compare across ketamine delivery routes (IV, IM, sublingual, compounded)?
Spravato is intranasal only, self-administered under observation. IV infusion is 100% bioavailable and the most-studied off-label route; IM is similar but injected rather than dripped. Sublingual troches/lozenges are roughly 25–30% bioavailable, so the dose is higher to compensate, and they're usually self-administered at home through a telehealth program rather than in a clinic. Our <a href="/guides/ketamine">ketamine guide</a> has the full route-by-route breakdown. One distinction worth naming: "street" or recreational ketamine is neither dosed, tested for purity, nor legal to obtain that way — it is not a cheaper version of a clinical or Spravato protocol, just an unregulated and legally risky one.